Post

What Stuck After the Convenience Trap

Not a full audit. Just the privacy tools and habits that stuck a year after the Convenience Trap series.

What Stuck After the Convenience Trap

After I finished the Convenience Trap series last year, I kept telling myself I’d come back with a more personal update. It took a while. This isn’t a full audit, and it’s definitely not a “here’s the perfect setup” guide. It’s just where my head’s at now and which tools actually stuck around.

The main idea from those posts still holds up for me. Most of the privacy we lose doesn’t go in some big dramatic breach. It goes through small, automatic decisions we barely notice. What’s changed is my focus. I care less about locking everything down as hard as possible these days. I’d rather just cut down how much unnecessary data leaves my devices in the first place.

The Stack That’s Stuck

Browser

Firefox is still my main browser, with some stricter settings turned on. I’ve been trying Brave too, and honestly I like it. If someone asks me what browser to use, Brave is usually what I tell them. But for whatever reason I keep drifting back to Firefox. Old habits, I guess.

When I’m just browsing and not logged into anything, I use Mullvad Browser. It’s built to make everyone look the same, which helps a lot with fingerprinting.

Lately I’ve also been playing around with Whonix, mostly out of curiosity. I’ve got it running in Virtual Machine Manager on my Fedora box. If you haven’t heard of it, Whonix is split into two separate virtual machines. One is the Gateway, and its only job is sending all your traffic through Tor. The other is the Workstation, where you actually do stuff. The Workstation can only reach the internet through the Gateway, so even if an app misbehaves or something nasty gets in, it has no way to leak your real IP address. Pretty clever. Is it practical for everyday use? Not really, at least not for me. But it was fun to dig into, and it taught me a lot about how isolation works in practice.

Passwords and accounts

Bitwarden handles almost everything. The biggest real win has been giving every account a unique password, even the ones I used to think didn’t matter. It sounds boring, but it’s probably the single change I’d recommend first to anyone.

Email and VPN

Proton Mail and Proton VPN have replaced the random mix of free tools and default providers I used to rely on.

On the email side, I’ve also gotten a lot pickier about who gets my real address. These days most services get an alias through SimpleLogin instead, and it forwards everything to my Proton Mail inbox. If one of those aliases starts getting spam, I know exactly who leaked or sold it, and I can just shut it off. Proton owns SimpleLogin, so since I already pay for Proton I get some extra features on top. Nice little bonus.

As for VPNs, I still really like Mullvad, and IVPN is great too. But I’m already paying for Proton, so their VPN is what I use. Simple as that. I mostly turn it on when I’m away from my own network. At home I care more about what the network itself is doing.

DNS filtering

My Raspberry Pi running Pi-hole is still going strong. It’s one of the few things that shows me what’s actually talking to the outside world. I’ve looked at Technitium and AdGuard Home, but Pi-hole has been stable enough that I’ve never felt like I needed to switch. Blocking ads is nice. Really, though, I keep it around because of what it lets me see.

The problem is that Pi-hole only helps while I’m at home. So for my iPhone, I use NextDNS. It’s basically Pi-hole in the cloud. You point your device’s DNS at it and get blocklists, tracker filtering, and logs of what your phone is trying to reach, no matter what network you’re on. On the iPhone you just install a profile and forget about it. Between Pi-hole at home and NextDNS on my phone, most of my bases are covered.

Network-level awareness

On the Mac, Little Snitch has been really useful for seeing which apps are phoning home and when. It doesn’t fix much by itself. What it does is make the “convenience trap” visible in real time, and that’s been eye-opening.

What Changed in My Thinking

A year ago I was mostly focused on the big tradeoffs: social logins, location permissions, default settings. Those still matter. But lately the quieter stuff has been more interesting to me. Apps hang onto permissions long after you stop using the feature that needed them. A surprising amount of a device’s traffic is telemetry and has nothing to do with what you opened it for. And most services need way less from you than they ask for.

I’ve also gotten more skeptical of “privacy-focused” tools that still want you to make an account with them. That’s a big part of why I started self-hosting a little on a mini PC. Right now it runs SearXNG for search, FreshRSS for my feeds, and Hermes Agent in a Podman container. Hermes is an open-source AI agent, and I like that I can run it on my own hardware instead of handing everything to some company’s cloud. Not all of it has been life-changing. But every one of these makes me ask a useful question: do I actually need the cloud version of this?

None of this is airtight. I still use an iPhone and a Mac every day. My goal isn’t “minimize every possible identifier” anymore. Now it’s more like: make passive collection a little harder by default, and keep a clearer view of what’s leaving my network.

And yes, I know. GrapheneOS. I love the project and I really want to try it someday. But right now the iPhone is just easier, and I’m not about to make everyone I know download Signal to keep in touch with me. Maybe one day.

Still Figuring Out

The messy parts are the ones that involve other people. Group chats, shared docs, work accounts, family stuff. That’s where a lot of the convenience I cut out elsewhere sneaks right back in. I don’t think there’s a clean fix for it. You just decide, case by case, how much friction is worth it.

If you’ve found tools or habits that held up over time, I’d love to hear about them, especially anything DNS, email, or self-hosting related. What stuck? What didn’t? In my experience, the setup that works is the one you eventually stop thinking about.

This post is licensed under CC BY 4.0 by the author.